Saturday, May 10, 2014

Some Quotations on the Visibility of the Catholic Church and the Authority of Synods

Protestants have done a very bad job of late at communicating to themselves and to others the biblical (and historic presbyterian) idea that there is to be one formally visible catholic church in the world (as opposed to a bunch of independent congregations or denominations).  That is why those outside of the Protestant world often think that we have no concept of the catholic visible church.  I've discussed this here and here and it is also evident in a couple of quotations I have come across lately from Eastern Orthodox (I'll call them the "Greeks" for short) sources:

Most Protestants do not seem very distressed over the multiplicity of denominations because, in their minds, the Church of Christ is to be found invisibly scattered among all true believers. Technically speaking, we can say that Protestant ecclesiology does not hold the view that the Church is in any sense a visible organism.  (This is from a book entitled His Broken Body by Laurent Cleenewerck, published in 2007 by Euclid University Consortium Press [Washington, D.C.], p. 32.)

Unlike the denominationalism of the Protestant world, the various churches of Orthodoxy really do have to talk to each other and work things out. A Presbyterian and a Lutheran may each recognize each other as Christian, but they have almost no stake in each other’s internal church life. The same even holds true of someone belonging to the PCA and someone belonging to the PCUSA (both Presbyterian denominations). They don’t have to work anything out between them. A PCA church plant does not in any way infringe on the territory of the PCUSA, because they’re not the same church.

Orthodoxy may often bicker and fight (though most parishioners never see this unless they happen to be in a dysfunctional parish), but the fact that we have such bickering and fighting with each other means that we recognize in each other that we are one Church, that we have a problem and that we need to fix it. Protestants always have the option of just splitting (and once splits occur, they don’t have to bother with each other), while Roman Catholics can ultimately appeal to the Vatican, who can impose solutions that work for the Vatican but might not work for everyone else involved.  (This is from "12 Reasons Why I Became and/or Remain an Orthodox Christian," by Father Andrew Stephen Damick, from his blog "Roads from Emmaus," reason #5: "Orthodoxy really is one Church.")

The problem with this is that Protestants, or at least historic Reformed Protestants, do actually have the concept of the catholic church as a visible organic body, in spite of our failure oftentimes to fully realize it and put it into practice.  (We can learn something from the Romanists and the Greeks on this point.)

Two historic Reformed writings on church government (among many others--I just happened to be reading in both of these recently) bring this point out clearly:  Samuel Rutherford's Due Right of Presbyteries (1644), and Samuel Hudson's A Vindication of the Essence and Unity of the Church-Catholick Visible (1658).  These are both excellent books that I would highly recommend.  Rutherford's book is extremely long and can be tough reading.  Hudson's book is a bit shorter and somewhat easier to read, with a more refined central thesis.  Below are a few quotations from each of these.

First of all, here is a quotation from Hudson's "The Epistle Dedicatory," addressed to "the Reverend Assembly of Divines assembled at Westminster":

My principal scope in this and the former Thesis, is to prove that there is one Church-Catholick visible on earth, and that God's intention and donation of the Ordinances of worship and discipline, was first to the whole Church, and secondarily to the particular Churches, as parts thereof.  And yet I acknowledge the ordinary and constant exercise of those Ordinances is primarily in the particular Churches, and a secondary and onely occasional exercise of them in greater parts thereof; and a very rare exercise of them in the whole conjunctim upon some general extraordinary occasion, and that can be no otherwise, then by delegated commissioners from the several parts of the whole, when convenible.

Edmund Callamy wrote an "Epistle to the Reader" at the front of Hudson's book.  Here is a selection from it:

For the truth is, the position there held forth, if granted, would utterly overthrow the grounds and pillars of the Congregationall government.  For if there be a Church-Catholick visible, and this Church be not onely a Church-Entitive but a Church Organicall, and a Totum integrale having all Church-power habitually seated in the Officers of it, which they have commission from Christ to exert, and put into act upon a lawfull call.  And if particular Congregations are integrall parts and members of the Church-Catholick, as the Jewish Synagogues were of the Jewish Church.  And if the Ministry, Ordinances, and censures were given by Christ first to the Church-general visible, and secondarily to the Church particular, Then it will necessarily follow, That the particular Congregation is not the first receptacle of Church-power, And that all Church-power is not intirely and independently in a particular Congregation, which are two of the chief foundations of the Congregationall government.  I shall not at all speak to the first, but as for this last, That all Church-power is solely and independently in a particular Congregation, it seems to me not onely to be contrary to the Scriptures, but to the very light of nature, and to carry many great absurdities with it.  For,

1. It takes away all authoritative appeals, and all authoritative waies of uniting particular Churches one with another.

2. Then the Churches of Jesus Christ should have no Church-communion in discipline one with another.  They may have Christian-communion, but no Church-communion.

3. Then no Minister could preach as an Officer out of his own Congregation, but onely as a gifted brother, and as a private Christian.

4.  Then no Minister could administer the Sacraments (which is an act of office) out of his own Congregation, nor (as I conceive) give the Sacrament to a member of another Congregation.

5. Then when his particular Church is dissolved, hee ceaseth to be a Minister, and must receive a New Ordination.

6. Then a Minister baptizing a childe, baptizeth him onely into his own Congregation.  For if he be not an Officer of the Catholick Church, he cannot baptize into the Catholick Church, which is directly contrary to 1 Cor. 12.13.

7. Then when the Officers excommunicate a person, he should onely be excommunicated out of that particular Congregation, &c.

8. Then Christ should have as many intire bodies as particular Congregations; Christ should not onely have one Body whereof particular Congregations are part, but every Congregation should be a Body of Christ by it selfe.

9. It would make way for toleration of heresies and blasphemies, and let in as many religions as there are particular Congregations.

10. It would make the Churches of Christ stand divided one from another in respect of government, and thereby bring ruine upon one another.  Even as in a civill state, if particular Corporations should be independent from the whole in point of government, it would quickly bring destruction upon the whole.

For the removing of these and such like absurdities, This learned learned and judicious Author [speaking of Samuel Hudson] in the Book fore-mentioned laid down a quite contrary Thesis.  That there is a Catholick visible, organicall Church, to which Ordinances and censures are firstly given by Jesus Christ.  And that every Minister is seated by God in this Catholick visible Church, and hath a virtuall and habitual power to preach as a Minister in any place where he shall be lawfully called.  Indeed he is not an actuall Minister of the Church-Catholick, nor hath actually the charge of the whole Church as the Apostles had, but habitually onely by reason of the indefinitenesse of his office.  He hath power in actu primo by virtue of his office, though not in actu secundo sive exercito, hee hath jus ad rem every where, but not in re any where, without a call.  He is a Minister of Jesus Christ, and thereby hath right and power to perform the acts belonging to his office, but for the execution of it, there is required a call thereunto.

A couple more quotes from Hudson:

The division of the Church-Catholick into particular Congregations, seemeth to me to bee no further of divine institution, then as it fitly serveth for order and edification, by cohabitation, for injoyment of God's Ordinances together publickly (as the Jewish Church was divided by Synagogues, for their constant enjoyment of Word, praier, and discipline, which they could not constantly enjoy, as a Nationall Church, by their Nationall worship thrice in the year) and the same reason will by proportion carry it for Classicall, Provinciall, and Nationall divisions, for community of a greater part of the Church.  (p. 17)

The nature of Synods is all one, whether they be Provinciall, Nationall, or Oecumenicall, and they only differ as greater or lesse, but their power in reference to their precincts, and delegation is alike.  They differ from Presbyteries called Classes, because the Provinciall is constituted only of certain delegated members from the classical Presbyteries of the same Province; the National of delegated members from the Provincial Synods; and the Oecumenical of delegated members from the National Synods; whereas the Classis is constituted of the Elders of the particular Congregations combined together.  The Classes are more frequent, constant, and ordinary in their meetings, the other more rare and extraordinary.  The power of Synods is not at all civil, but Ecclesiastical, neither is it destructive to the power of Classes, or single Congregations, but perfective and conservative.  They are not infallible, but may err as well as a Classis, or single Eldership, yet are not so subject thereto, because in the multitude of Counsellours there is safety, and they consist of more choice able men, and not so liable to personal prejudice against the accused, nor likely to be swaied by fear, or favour, or sinister respects.  Their power is not meerly consultatory and suasive, but authoritative, and to be submitted unto by those for whom their delegation is, so farr as their acts are according to the Word of God. (pp. 158-159)

And here's a quote from Rutherford's Due Right of Presbyteries:

Synods are necessary for the well-being of the Church, and still are in the visible Church in more, or lesse degrees, for the authority of Synods consisting of six onely, differeth not in nature and essence, from a generall councell of the whole Catholicke visible Church.  Magis et minus non variant speciem.  And therefore if Synods be warranted by the word of God, (as no question they are) there is no neede to prove by particular places of the word, the lawfulnesse of every one of these, a sessionall meeting of the Eldership of a single Congregation. 2. A Presbytery, or meeting of Elders, or Pastors & Doctors of more Congregations. 3. A Provinciall Synod of the Presbyteries of a whole province. 4. The Nationall Assembly, or meeting of the Elders of the whole Nation. 5. The generall and Oecumenick Councell of Pastors, Doctors, and Elders of the whole Catholick Church visible, for all these differ not in essence, but degrees, and what word of God, as Matt. 18.16,17, proveth the lawfulnesse of one, is for the lawfulnesse of all the five sorts of Synods. (pp. 331-332 [second batch of page numbers])

These selections show, in contrast to modern popular opinion, that the historic Reformed faith does indeed hold to the concept of a formally visible, organic catholic church.  Church authority does not reside only in the elders (the session) of individual congregations but is collegial in nature, so that church authority can (and should) be exercised not only in congregational sessions, but in presbyteries and higher synods (including provincial, national, and ecumenical synods).  The formal catholic unity of the church and the collegiality of church power imply the impermissibility of both congregationalism and denominationalism (the idea that de jure ecclesiastical legitimacy and authority can reside in multiple, independent denominations or clumps of congregations).

For more, see here and here, and in general here.

UPDATE 6/4/14:  In his earlier work on the nature and unity of the church, Essence and Unity of the Church Catholic Visible, found in the Anthology of Presbyterian and Reformed Literature, vol. 5, ed. by Chris Coldwell (Dallas, TX: Naphtali Press, 1992), Samuel Hudson quotes approvingly a description of the visible church from Lutheran theologian Johann Gerhard:

We have established the fact that the Church is a certain universal extended object, spread out through the orb, described to us in holy Scripture, which by means of a certain visible administration constitutes a singular ecclesiastical organic body, in which are comprised all the individual classical, provincial and national churches entirely as its parts.

UPDATE 6/9/14:  Here is a well-articulated comment from church historian James Walker:

The visible church, in the idea of the Scottish theologians, is catholic. You have not an indefinite number of Parochial, or Congregational, or National churches, constituting, as it were, so many ecclesiastical individualities, but one great spiritual republic, of which these various organizations form a part. The visible church is not a genus, so to speak, with so many species under it. It is thus you may think of the State, but the visible church is a totum integrale, it is an empire. The churches of the various nationalities constitute the provinces of this empire; and though they are so far independent of each other, yet they are so one, that membership in one is membership in all, and separation from one is separation from all . . . This conception of the church, of which, in at least some aspects, we have practically so much lost sight, had a firm hold of the Scottish theologians of the seventeenth century.' (James Walker, The Theology and Theologians of Scotland. Edinburgh: Knox Press, [1888] 1982. Lecture iv. pp.95-6.)

Thursday, May 8, 2014

Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction

I had a discussion a couple of days ago with a deacon in the Eastern Orthodox Church who is a friend of mine.  During the discussion, the topic of the status of the Pope in the Eastern Church came up.  My friend made the statement that the Pope (and the Roman Catholic Church in general) is considered schismatic from the Eastern point of view and lacking in any legitimate, de jure jurisdiction as a bishop in the church.  As a manifestation of this fact, he mentioned that Eastern Orthodox persons living, say, in Rome do not join the Roman Catholic Church (as they would do if the Pope really was the legitimate Bishop of Rome), but instead are members of some Eastern Orthodox Church under the jurisdiction of some Eastern Orthodox archdiocese, etc.

The Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland has a congregation in Santa Fe, TX, USA.  This is very noteworthy.  What is a church of Scotland doing in Texas?  The same thing an Eastern Orthodox Church is doing in Western Rome.  The presence of a Scottish church in Texas implies a rejection of the legitimacy of American churches (including Presbyterian/Reformed churches).  If there was a legitimate US church, the FPCS would surely defer to that body.*  There are several Reformed churches, including a number of PCA churches and two OPC churches, in the Houston area (where Santa Fe is located).  If these churches were seen as legitimate, it would be schismatic to plant a Scottish church in that same area, drawing members away from these American churches.

The FPCS is the only de jure denomination existing in the world today.  This is the FPCS's point of view, as evidenced by its beliefs about unity and schism as well as by its practice of planting churches in other nations.  There are FPCS churches on five continents:  "In the present day, the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland has congregations in Scotland, England, Northern Ireland, Canada, USA, Ukraine, Israel, Singapore, Kenya, Zimbabwe, Australia and New Zealand."  (This is from the Sydney FP website.)  The recent Catechism of the History and Principles of the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland (see also here) points out clearly the presbyterian conviction that "unity is an absolute duty," from which flows the concomitant conclusion that the church should be one in visible unity throughout the earth and thus that when churches are not united, there is an implicit charge of schism from one church to the other and the churches are rejecting each others' de jure legitimacy and authority as churches:

106 Q. What is meant by Christ’s Church being Catholic?A. The word Catholic means Universal, which teaches us that the Church of Christ is one in all nations. 
141 Q. Is the Free Presbyterian Church opposed to union with other Churches?A. No, the Free Presbyterian Church encourages biblical union with any Church in Scotland or overseas provided that there is a unity in doctrine, worship, government, discipline, and practice. 
146 Q. When should individual believers separate from the fellowship of others?A. The Scriptures enjoin believers to withdraw themselves from those who are professed brethren and who walk disorderly (2 Thess. 3:6), so when men have so rejected sound doctrine, right government, and discipline, or have introduced superstitious worship, or are maintaining a schismatic position, and when an orderly correction of these evils fails, then believers are to separate from such. 
147 Q. When is it lawful to break ecclesiastical union through separation?A. Unity is an absolute duty and therefore the only lawful reason for separation is when one is compelled unavoidably to sin in order to maintain the bond of union. In this case the sin of schism is made by those compelling to sin. Up until this point any separation would be unjust schism since one may still testify against corruptions in the Church and use all lawful means to have them removed. 
148 Q. What is schism?A. Schism is a breach of the union and communion that ought to exist within the visible Church in doctrine, government and worship (1 Cor. 12:25; Rom. 16:17).

On the website of the FPCS, in an FAQ section, we read this:

Being a Presbyterian church we believe in the unity of congregations in a Presbyterian structure. We do not believe in the spurious unity of the modern ecumenical movement which minimises doctrinal difference between the Protestant churches and which is leading towards re-union with Roman Catholicism under the pope of Rome. We believe in the unity of all Spirit-taught, born-again, believers in Christ throughout the world, and that they ought to be united in one Presbyterian Church.

These conclusions have also been spelled out explicitly in various articles by FP ministers, elders, and members (such as here, here, here, and here). The last article just cited puts it this way:

Denominational walls are erected on a judicial level and the distinct jurisdiction of church courts is the final and fullest expression of separation. The setting up of rival Church courts from Kirk Session through to General Assembly is an express rejection of the jurisdiction of the Church courts of other denominations and is either schismatic itself or necessarily charges other bodies with the sin of schism. Persisting in such separation is either schismatic or else there is an implicit charge of schism against all those from whom separation is maintained.

Since the Synod of the FPCS is not in communion with any other church anywhere in the world, it follows that the Synod claims to be the only legitimate group of churches known to exist on the earth at this time (not to exclude the possibility of orthodox churches made up of believers lost in the Amazon rain forest or in other ways out of contact with the rest of human society).  It follows from this that the extent of the jurisdiction of the FPCS Synod is the entirety of planet earth, not just Scotland.  If I were to ask, "Which synod's jurisdiction do I fall under living here in Orem, UT?", the answer must be "The Synod of the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland," for there is no other legitimate synod.  (There are plenty of de facto churches full of true believers, but no de jure churches that should be formally recognized.)  If I had lived in Germany in the year 34 AD, which synod's jurisdiction would I have been under?  I would have been under the jurisdiction of the church in Jerusalem, for there was no other church at that time.  It would be years before the church would be able to reach well into Germany, but it could not have claimed that any believers who might live in Germany were not the responsibility of the church which at that time was in Jerusalem, for believers are to be subject to valid elders, and they can only be subject to valid elders who actually exist.  In a presbyterian system of church government, elders in the church function collegially as a body ruling over the entire catholic church, so any de jure church members anywhere are, by definition, under the jurisdiction of the highest ruling council of the church, and those who are seeking membership fall under their jurisdiction as well.

For more, see here and here.

*Or, if somehow both jurisdictions ended up being present in the same place, at least the situation would be regarded as a temporary confusion to be sorted out as quickly as possible, like the situation with the various jurisdictions of Eastern Orthodox churches in the US.  My friend, the Eastern Orthodox deacon, described the situation to me in an email in this way:

The Church in America was originally under Moscow until it was mature enough to be self governing, but once the Communist Revolution took over Russia things got complicated and people feared Moscow's leadership to potentially be compromised.  So people began to appeal to the motherlands of Orthodoxy, usually based on ethnic categories, to have priests sent, or bishops consecrated, etc., which ended up causing the rather uncanonical situation of overlapping jurisdictions. There is hope, though. The Ecumenical Patriarch called a meeting of the bishops of America to begin working this out so that we can have regularization of the situation in America and the rest of the diaspora.

UPDATE 5/9/14:  A couple of further thoughts:

1. I acknowledge that there are probably all kinds of creative ways to justify having a church of Scotland in Texas for those who don't want to acknowledge that separate presbyterian denominations are rejecting each others' de jure legitimacy and authority, so it is probably the case that the existence of a Scottish church in Texas doesn't necessarily imply, in all possible hypothetical scenarios, that the Scottish church rejects the legitimacy of American churches or even churches in the Houston area.  However, as there are lots of other reasons to conclude that separated presbyterian denominations don't accept each others' legitimacy, this fact is no problem for that thesis.

One other explanation for why there might be a Scottish church in Texas is that the Christian Scots of Texas want to have a distinctly Scottish ethnic church.  This is not the actual reason the FP church in Santa Fe exists, but it is a possible hypothetical reason some Scottish church in Texas might have for existing.  My response to this would be that as the church is called to be one Body, "where there is neither Greek nor Jew, circumcision nor uncircumcision, Barbarian, Scythian, bond nor free" (Colossians 3:11), I think it would be inappropriate for there to be separate church bodies divided from each other along ethnic lines (except in cases of practical necessity, such as when there are two groups who don't at all speak the same language or something like that).

2. To help further to get a feel for what it means to have a church rooted in one jurisdiction far away from its own turf and deep into the territory of another jurisdiction, think of one American denomination, the OPC.  Here is a list of the various presbytery jurisdictions of the OPC.  Imagine that the Presbytery of New York and New England attempted to plant a church in the Houston, TX, area, keeping the planted church indefinitely under their own jurisdiction rather than under the jurisdiction of the Presbytery of the Southwest (within which Houston lies).  Would not the Presbytery of the Southwest ordinarily see this as a slight against their jurisdiction, an implicit rejection of their authority and competency to handle the churches in their area?  Would it not be seen as inappropriate and irregular?

UPDATE 9/30/14:  Here is an interesting article by Eastern Orthodox Father Andrew Stephen Damick discussing the jurisdictional issues facing Eastern Orthodoxy in America. 

UPDATE 11/18/14:  I just came across this nice map of OPC presbyteries.  And, while we're at it, here is a list of congregations in the FPCS.  We don't seem to have a presbytery map on the website.  If, some day, we do, perhaps I'll post it here.

UPDATE 1/7/15:  Here is another article on the Eastern Orthodox Church's jurisdictional situation in America, with some very good points about why it is inappropriate, where it can be helped, to have jurisdictional overlap.  The visible expression of the unity of the church is compromised when there are choices of jurisdictions in the same area.  Rather, all de jure Christians in an area should be required, normally, to be united to each other and to elders based on boundaries decided "by the respective bounds of their dwellings" (as the Form of Presbyterial Church Government puts it)."[R]espect of persons" should be excluded in deciding canonical church boundaries, which includes ethnic and other cultural differences unless these constitute unavoidable practical obstacles to fellowship (such as an inability to communicate).  So we Presbyterians completely agree with the Eastern Orthodox on this point.

Wednesday, April 9, 2014

Is Secularism Unprincipled?

Below is my republication of an article which originally appeared on the blog "Rationally Speaking", maintained by Prof. Massimo Pigliucci, a philosopher at the City University of New York.  The article was written by Ian Pollock.  It was published under the Creative Commons License, which is why it is legal to republish it here.  No changes have been made in the article.

I am republishing it here because I think it does an excellent job of pointing out the non-neutrality of secularism, in spite of its loud and constant claims to be neutral.  Polluck himself holds a Naturalistic (Atheistic) worldview.  I've commented a tiny bit on this article here.  I also engaged in some substantive dialogue over the ideas expressed in this article in the comments section of the original article.

The secular movement is a cause that, by and large, I support. I think a more secular society would be a better one. But I think some of the purported arguments for secularism are in one way or another bad arguments. Here, I attempt to prod secularists into some critical reflection on their ideas.

As secularists would be wise to point out more often, secularism does not mean the promotion of atheism in anywise. In fact, the historical roots of secularism lie in the desire of non-dominant faiths to enjoy legal protection against the persecutions of majority religions. This is a very good reason to enforce a firewall between the promotion of atheism and the promotion of secularism — both may or may not be worthy goals, but they are not the same goal.

The modern secular ideal goes roughly as follows: “government institutions and individuals charged with them should be separated from religious institutions and the people charged with them.” This idea has a long pedigree that includes ancient and mediaeval thinkers such as Epicurus and Ibn Rushd, as well as moderns such as Locke, Jefferson and Rawls.

The modern secular movement is committed to two main principles: (1) religions are welcome to participate in moral and political debate in the public sphere, so long as they use language and arguments that are at least in principle accessible to all participants in the public sphere; (2) the state may not endorse any one religious perspective over any other.

As an example of principle (1), if a Muslim wishes to ban artistic portrayals of Mohammad because such betrayals are considered morally wrong by their faith, they can’t simply argue that “This contravenes my faith.” Rather, they must come up with a secular argument that does not directly use a faith perspective (though it may still mention it). For example, they could opt for a quasi-utilitarian argument along the lines of “Depictions of Mohammad are deeply offensive to most Muslims; ceteris paribus, it is bad to egregiously offend people; therefore, depictions of Mohammad should be banned.” This may or may not be a good argument, but it is at least valid, and in principle a Christian, Hindu or atheist could go along with its logic.

As an example of principle (2), if a Christian wishes to promote the Ten Commandments, they must do so using private resources and on private property; they may not, for example, put up a statue of Moses with the TC on a public space such as a courthouse lawn, with public money.

(One important note regarding principle (2): state promotion of atheism counts as promoting a religious perspective, so regimes such as the former Soviet Union are in violation of the principles of secularism.)

As Julian Baggini points out in the Guardian, this vision of secularism is probably the best way to move societies with a plurality of religions forward while preventing sectarian gridlock and possible violence. It is imperative that religious people, moderates in particular, be convinced of such a view, which is why it may be a good idea to pick one’s fights by steering away from battling the more trivial violations of these principles in order to focus on the really serious violations.

The pragmatic adequacy of this ideal is, I think, very easy to argue for and very robust. With much relaxation of the above two principles, one ends up at best with sectarian conflict, and at worst with some shade of theocracy.

There is just one problem with it, which is that whatever its pragmatic worth, both of its principles are ultimately founded on special pleading — i.e., both of its principles are unprincipled. Certain groups of religious people notice this lack of principle. Because of this, the above understanding of secularism leads to inevitable pathologies in political debate.

Let’s start with principle (1), that religions and worldviews may participate in the public sphere so long as they “translate” their views into secular language accessible to all participants.

Our first and most important objection is that there is no principled difference between religious beliefs and secular beliefs. Religious beliefs can (according to their proponents) be backed up by some sort of line of reasoning, even if it’s a bad one, just like secular beliefs.

Suppose I wish to defend my view that non-marital sex is a moral evil. All I have to do is explain that my holy book says that, and then give evidence for the miraculous predictions my holy book has made which verify its general trustworthiness, and I have (contrary to appearances) completed a fully secular argument. (Not a good one — but that is no criterion for automatic exclusion!)

How is that any different from a pundit weighing in on economic policy, then explaining why his Keynesian approach has always been successful in predicting the effects of economic policy? Why is one of these people required to “translate” or shut up, and the other not?

Second, the demand to “translate,” even if accepted, leads to pathologies in public debate. Specifically, it forces religious believers into a position of insincerity. Given that I believe non-marital sex is morally bad and should be prevented, how am I to make my case without referencing my faith? By sheer sophistry, of course. Perhaps I opt for a utilitarian sophistry: sex outside of marriage leads to depression and suicide. Now the public sphere is polluted not merely with mistakes but with lies.

What about principle (2), that the state should take no position on religious questions?

This principle fails due to the same lack of a principled distinction between secular versus religious questions. Suppose I believe that 2015 will be the beginning of the End Times, when the world will be consumed in a great war involving all countries. Is this a religious question? Not for me. It’s a practical question: I already started buying the cans of lentils for my bomb shelter.

Suppose further that enough of the population agrees with me that they elect me Prime Minister. On what earthly basis can I “take no position” on the question of the End Times because it’s a “religious question”? Am I to abandon my country to the massacre and famine I know is coming?

This example is extreme, but the same applies to more mundane concerns. When it comes to policy, every question is potentially a religious question.

How could we ever think otherwise? I think the mistake arises from the differing epistemic status of “belief” among two groups of people, whom I will call True Believers and Professors (borrowing the terminology from Daniel Dennett).

True Believers are people who are convinced of religious propositions in the same way that they are convinced of any other proposition, such as that Mexico is to the south of the USA. They have seen some evidence which convinces them, and they are now willing to act as if the religious propositions are straightforwardly true. You know those people, so beloved of the atheist blogosphere, who pray for their kids instead of taking them to the hospital? Those are classic True Believers.

Professors are people who nominally adhere to some system of religious doctrine as part of their identity, but whose epistemology does not, when push comes to shove, actually contain all of those doctrines — particularly as concerns worldly affairs. For example, Professors believe in the power of prayer, but as a way of dealing with loss, not as a means for deciding whether to bomb Damascus. Somewhere in their heart of hearts is a bit of common sense, and it holds an override switch.

We can see that the distinction between “religious questions” and “secular questions” makes a great deal of sense for Professors. Religious questions are basically de facto questions of identity, however much they are dressed up as propositional belief. John F. Kennedy is loyal to the Catholic identity, which theoretically includes papal infallibility, but don’t worry! He isn’t literally going to do whatever the Pope tells him to.

To True Believers, such a distinction is sheer gobbledigook. I’m forced to admit they have a point, at least on this question.

The ultimate unprincipledness of the two tenets of secularism is beginning to be noticed. For example, Michael Sandel has recently begun to argue that irreducibly religious (as well as, presumably, antireligious) arguments should be acceptable in political debate. It is hard to argue with his logic: policy proposals depend on moral claims, and moral claims depend on some substantive vision of the good life. Philosophically, it all rings true; pragmatically, it sounds like a potential recipe for sectarian civil war.

How did we get into this bizarre situation in which the only way to have a workable, non-sectarian political process is to exclude, via outright special pleading, explicitly religious viewpoints from the public sphere and from the law?

I believe that secularism, as imagined above, arises more or less as follows:

  • Participation of citizens with differing views in political debate is supposed to be part of the democratic process.
  • However, a large fraction of citizens hold some views that are (in the judgment of more sober minds) straightforwardly insane, and would not hesitate to impose the policy implications of those views upon the rest of society if given the ability to do so.
  • Religious moderates, religious minorities and non-believers, tacitly recognizing these two facts, promote secularism as a compromise, despite its philosophical bankruptcy and practical pathologies.
Seen in this light, it is obvious why secularism cannot really be principled. It is an attempt to consign certain groups of sincere but deluded religious believers to a rhetorical sandbox.

Sometimes a matter of great practical import must override a matter of principle, however. The philosophically correct picture, as far as I can see, is a public policy debate in which any argument (religious or not) is permitted, and there is no false distinction between religious and secular questions. The sanity of the majority prevails, epistemically bad views lose to epistemically good ones in the marketplace of public opinion, and we all ride our unicorns into the sunset.

We should probably just stick with the old, unprincipled hack. But let us at least be honest with ourselves about what it is.

Monday, April 7, 2014

Could Divided Denominations Be in Partial Communion with Each Other?

I have argued in many posts, such as here and here, that when denominations are separate from each other they are necessarily (assuming a presbyterian system of church government) exercising discipline against each other, charging each other with schism, and rejecting each others' de jure legitimacy and authority.

A person might accept this basic line of reasoning but partially object to the conclusion, perhaps, in this way:

"OK, I accept that churches are exercising ecclesiastical discipline against each other when they refuse to be united to each other denominationally.  I accept that they are not accepting each other as sister churches in good standing.  But perhaps they are not entirely, but only partially, rejecting each others' de jure legitimacy and authority.  To make a comparison, a presbytery might suspend a pastor from certain rights and duties ordinarily associated with his office without entirely revoking his pastoral role or authority.  For example, they might suspend his right to vote in presbytery meetings while refraining from suspending his right to function as a teacher in his congregation.  Likewise, perhaps two denominations might put each other partially under discipline and revoke some of each others' rights, such as the right to vote in a common general assembly, while still assigning some rights to each other, such as the right to rule over congregations, etc."

This is my response to this line of argumentation:

1. First of all, I acknowledge that the argument is correct in pointing out that what it describes could, theoretically (with some qualifications, as noted below), be a state of affairs between two churches.  In this case, the denominations would not be entirely separate from each other but only partially separate.

But there are problems with this argument as well, both theoretical and actual:

2. As a matter of fact, no denomination actually understands its relationship to another denomination in this way.  The OPC and the FPCS, for example, do not have any formal relationship with each other whatsoever.  There is no formal granting of any rights, responsibilities, or duties, from one denomination to the other.  There is nothing in the minutes of any OPC court which acknowledges FPCS pastors or elders to be on the roll of the church as pastors and elders, but under some specific disciplinary action.  Nor is there anything like this in the records of the FPCS.  But this is the sort of thing we would have to see in order to acknowledge that the situation suggested by the above argument actually describes any currently existing state of affairs.

3. There are also serious theoretical impediments to such a scenario.  If the OPC, for example, were to formally recognize FPCS officer and church courts as being formally recognized but under partial discipline, it is still the case that the FPCS would not agree to this characterization of itself.  FPCS courts and officers would not acknowledge themselves as being under discipline and as having any rights or duties revoked, and so they would continue to function as if they are not under such discipline.  It would be absurd for such a situation to carry on indefinitely.  If a presbytery brings discipline against an individual session, it expects that session to acknowledge that it is under discipline.  If the session refuses to acknowledge or submit to the judgment of the presbytery, the session will end up sinking deeper and deeper into stronger discipline until its authority is finally entirely revoked.  Thus, such a situation will be naturally unstable and tend to dissolve into complete separation before too long.

4. Another theoretical impediment is that it is difficult to imagine a sensible state of discipline in which voting rights in a higher church court are denied while full rights to rule over and teach in a congregation are maintained.  If a church court is not deemed competent because of sin or error to have a role in voting in a higher church court, why would they be deemed competent to rule or teach in a congregation?  Are the latter functions less important than the former?  If anything, I would think it would be the opposite, though I would say they are of equal importance.  Again, therefore, I would think that such a situation would be naturally unstable and, if anything, would simply be a very temporary stepping stone to either reconciliation or complete separation.  Such a situation would surely not constitute a long-lasting (even centuries-long!) permanent relationship.

For these reasons, therefore, I do not believe we can see the relationship between existing denominations in the way the argument envisions.  Rather, the kind of denominational division that actually exists between the various denominations today involves a refusal to grant any formal recognition to the de jure legitimacy and authority of other denominational church courts (though it does not necessarily involve rejection of the de facto being of the visible church in the various denominations).

(Someone might argue that fraternal relations between denominations constitute a form of partial de jure communion, but I would say that they do not.  Fraternal relations do not involve the formal granting of any rights or responsibilities to officers and church courts as such beyond denominational lines, or any acknowledgement that one denomination considers the other denomination to be under partial discipline.  I think that fraternal relations--assuming they have any coherent meaning at all in a presbyterian context--are best understood as an institutional recognition by one denomination that another denomination is a de facto part of the visible church of Christ along with a commitment to take certain steps of dialogue and action intended to work towards eventual de jure communion.  I discuss these ideas a bit more here and here.)

UPDATE 4/8/13:  Just briefly, I might add that I question whether a situation such as described by the argument dealt with above could even accurately be described as a situation involving separated denominations.  When a session is under discipline by a presbytery, we don't say they have become (even partly) two separate denominations.  We don't say they are now in "partial communion."  Rather, we look at the situation as two bodies that are in the same denomination, in full communion, but with one body under the discipline of the other.  So if was the case that the OPC looks at the FPCS as another branch of the formally recognized church, subject to mutually-binding councils but under discipline, I don't think we would describe this situation as one in which we have two distinct denominations interacting with each other.  Rather, we would say there is one denomination in which one body is under discipline from another body.

But this is not the situation between the OPC and the FPCS (or between any other divided denominations).  The fact is that the OPC and the FPCS are indeed separate denominations because they simply have no formal recognition of the de jure existence, legitimacy, or authority of each others' courts and officers.

Friday, March 14, 2014

Against Latitudinarianism

An erroneous viewpoint called latitudinarianism has become popular these days in evangelical circles, and even (to a lesser degree) in many Reformed circles.  I would define latitudinarianism as "the idea that the church does not have a duty to enforce on church members everything that God has taught in his Word, but only those things that are deemed to be essential to the gospel."  The idea is that there are certain doctrines and practices taught and commanded in God's Word which must be believed and/or followed for someone to be a truly saved, regenerate Christian, and there are other things taught and commanded which, if not followed (in at least somewhat sincere ignorance), do not imperil a person's regeneration.  So, for example, belief in Christ as God is usually considered to be essential to salvation, but not belief in (or practice of) infant baptism.  The practical conclusion latitudinarianism draws from this is that the church should enforce belief in Christ as God on church members, exercising church discipline on those who deny it or teach against it, but it should not enforce belief in or the practice of infant baptism on members, because it would be unjust of the church to demand more of people to be members in good standing in the Body of Christ than God does.  If God does not say that error regarding whether or not the children of believers should be baptized is an impediment to someone being regenerated and thus part of the people of God, who are we to deny membership in good standing to those who have fallen into this error?  Consequently, baptists should be allowed to be church members and should not be at all disciplined merely for believing and practicing their baptist convictions (by not baptizing their children, etc.).  Perhaps the classic watchword summing up the latitudinarian point of view is this phrase, well known in many evangelical circles:  "In essentials unity, in non-essentials liberty, in all things charity."

Now, I happen to agree with the idea that a distinction can be made between doctrines and practices that can be known to be inseparable from regeneration on the one hand and doctrines and practices that, so far as we know, a person could in a reasonable degree of innocent ignorance reject and still be regenerate.  I would agree that a person cannot truly reject Christ as God and be regenerate, but that, so far as I know from God's Word, a person might very well truly reject infant baptism and be regenerate.  In fact, I have high hopes that many baptists are truly regenerate.  So this is not the part of latitudinarianism I have a problem with.  (I'll come back to this issue later on.)  My problem is with the practical implication that is drawn from the distinction between "essential" and "non-essential" doctrines and practices--that churches cannot discipline members with regard to non-essentials.

THE CHURCH IS COMMANDED TO TEACH AND ENFORCE ALL THAT CHRIST HAS COMMANDED

My reason for opposing this latitudinarian idea is that the Bible seems pretty clearly to teach that the church not only may discipline church members for non-essential matters but that it has a duty to do so.  Let's take a look at some passages:

After his resurrection, Christ gave his "great commission" to the church:

Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost, teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you. (Matthew 28:19-20)

What is the church to teach all nations to observe?  Only those things deemed essential?  No, it is to teach people to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you.

What is to happen if someone refuses to obey anything Christ, and the church rightfully in his name, commands him to believe or observe?

Now we command you, brethren, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye withdraw yourselves from every brother that walketh disorderly, and not after the tradition which he received of us. . . . And if any man obey not our word by this epistle, note that man, and have no company with him, that he may be ashamed. Yet count him not as an enemy, but admonish him as a brother.  (2 Thessalonians 3:6, 14-15)

If anyone refuses to obey the teachings of the apostles, whereby they are communicating the commands of Christ, that person is to be subject to church discipline, even to being put out of the fellowship of the church for a time.  Paul says the same thing elsewhere:

Therefore, brethren, stand fast, and hold the traditions which ye have been taught, whether by word, or our epistle.  (2 Thessalonians 2:15) 
Now I praise you, brethren, that ye remember me in all things, and keep the ordinances, as I delivered them to you.  (1 Corinthians 11:2)
Now I beseech you, brethren, mark them which cause divisions and offences contrary to the doctrine which ye have learned; and avoid them. For they that are such serve not our Lord Jesus Christ, but their own belly; and by good words and fair speeches deceive the hearts of the simple.  (Romans 16:17)

This is a faithful saying, and these things I will that thou affirm constantly, that they which have believed in God might be careful to maintain good works. These things are good and profitable unto men. But avoid foolish questions, and genealogies, and contentions, and strivings about the law; for they are unprofitable and vain. A man that is an heretick [that is, one who causes divisions through false teaching] after the first and second admonition reject; knowing that he that is such is subverted, and sinneth, being condemned of himself.  (Titus 3:8-11)

This is in accordance with what Christ himself taught as to how to deal with sins and offenses in the church:

Moreover if thy brother shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone: if he shall hear thee, thou hast gained thy brother. But if he will not hear thee, then take with thee one or two more, that in the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established. And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the church: but if he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as an heathen man and a publican. Verily I say unto you, Whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever ye shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven. Again I say unto you, That if two of you shall agree on earth as touching any thing that they shall ask, it shall be done for them of my Father which is in heaven. For where two or three are gathered together in my name, there am I in the midst of them.  (Matthew 18:15-20)

It is also in accordance with the regular practice of the apostolic church . . .

Then they that gladly received his word were baptized: and the same day there were added unto them about three thousand souls. And they continued stedfastly in the apostles' doctrine and fellowship, and in breaking of bread, and in prayers.  (Acts 2:41-42)

And as they went through the cities, they delivered them the decrees for to keep, that were ordained of the apostles and elders which were at Jerusalem.  (Acts 16:4)

. . . and the teaching of God in the Old Testament with regard to his law:

What thing soever I command you, observe to do it: thou shalt not add thereto, nor diminish from it.  (Deuteronomy 12:32)

Notice that nothing is said in any of these passages regarding a distinction between "essential" and "non-essential" matters.  Do these passages seem consistent with the church saying to its members, "Hey, you need to believe and practice these doctrines and practices over here, because they're essential, but these non-essential ones over here you are free to ignore without any sanctions or discipline, without any threat to your good standing in the church"?  No, what Scripture commands church officers to do is to teach and enforce with the authority of Christ everything that Christ has commanded.  What God has made mandatory, man cannot make optional.  Disobedience to any one thing that God has commanded is disobedience to God.  I'm reminded of the comment of the Apostle James:

For whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet offend in one point, he is guilty of all. For he that said, Do not commit adultery, said also, Do not kill. Now if thou commit no adultery, yet if thou kill, thou art become a transgressor of the law.  (James 2:10-11)

If the church is commanded to teach and enforce what God has handed on to it to teach and enforce, it does not have the authority to decline to either teach or enforce any part of it, even on the grounds that it does not consider some parts of what God has commanded to be "essential."

ERROR, REGENERATION, AND CHURCH DISCIPLINE

Now, I mentioned earlier that latitudinarians claim that there is some kind of distinction between "essential" and "non-essential" doctrines and practices, the difference between them being that essential doctrines and practices are essential to a person's being regenerate, while non-essential doctrines and practices are, well, not essential to a person's being regenerate.  I think there is some biblical basis for this distinction.  It is evident from Scripture that there are some things that are simply incompatible with having a heart right with God (at least if they are persisted in indefinitely and unrepentantly).  A true, heartfelt rejection of the gospel, rightly understood, is one of those things.  So is disbelief in the existence of God.  So is (sincere and truly understood) idolatry.  See, for example, Romans 1:18-25, Luke 10:16, and Matthew 10:11-15:

For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who hold the truth in unrighteousness; because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath shewed it unto them. For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse: Because that, when they knew God, they glorified him not as God, neither were thankful; but became vain in their imaginations, and their foolish heart was darkened. Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools, and changed the glory of the uncorruptible God into an image made like to corruptible man, and to birds, and fourfooted beasts, and creeping things. Wherefore God also gave them up to uncleanness through the lusts of their own hearts, to dishonour their own bodies between themselves: Who changed the truth of God into a lie, and worshipped and served the creature more than the Creator, who is blessed for ever. Amen.

He that heareth you heareth me; and he that despiseth you despiseth me; and he that despiseth me despiseth him that sent me.

And into whatsoever city or town ye shall enter, enquire who in it is worthy; and there abide till ye go thence. And when ye come into an house, salute it. And if the house be worthy, let your peace come upon it: but if it be not worthy, let your peace return to you. And whosoever shall not receive you, nor hear your words, when ye depart out of that house or city, shake off the dust of your feet. Verily I say unto you, It shall be more tolerable for the land of Sodom and Gomorrha in the day of judgment, than for that city.

There are other examples as well.  If a person exhibits (and persists unrepentantly in) these kinds of attitudes or actions, it is a pretty clear sign that he is unregenerate.  We saw in some of the quotations I gave earlier illustrating the command to discipline church members that certain kinds of behavior not only deserve to receive formal discipline but are also a pretty clear sign of heart problems (in a spiritual sense).  For example, Romans 16:17 speaks of a certain kind of divisive attitude that Paul does not seem to think bodes well for a person's spiritual state:

Now I beseech you, brethren, mark them which cause divisions and offences contrary to the doctrine which ye have learned; and avoid them. For they that are such serve not our Lord Jesus Christ, but their own belly; and by good words and fair speeches deceive the hearts of the simple.

On the other hand, the Bible also gives indications that it is possible sometimes for people to be ignorant or confused about some things in such a way as to do things that are wrong without it necessarily meaning their hearts are not (at least to some degree) in the right place.  See, for example, Acts 18:24-28, 2 Chronicles 30:13-20, and Philippians 3:15:

And a certain Jew named Apollos, born at Alexandria, an eloquent man, and mighty in the scriptures, came to Ephesus. This man was instructed in the way of the Lord; and being fervent in the spirit, he spake and taught diligently the things of the Lord, knowing only the baptism of John. And he began to speak boldly in the synagogue: whom when Aquila and Priscilla had heard, they took him unto them, and expounded unto him the way of God more perfectly. And when he was disposed to pass into Achaia, the brethren wrote, exhorting the disciples to receive him: who, when he was come, helped them much which had believed through grace: For he mightily convinced the Jews, and that publicly, shewing by the scriptures that Jesus was Christ.

And there assembled at Jerusalem much people to keep the feast of unleavened bread in the second month, a very great congregation. And they arose and took away the altars that were in Jerusalem, and all the altars for incense took they away, and cast them into the brook Kidron. Then they killed the passover on the fourteenth day of the second month: and the priests and the Levites were ashamed, and sanctified themselves, and brought in the burnt offerings into the house of the Lord. And they stood in their place after their manner, according to the law of Moses the man of God: the priests sprinkled the blood, which they received of the hand of the Levites. For there were many in the congregation that were not sanctified: therefore the Levites had the charge of the killing of the passovers for every one that was not clean, to sanctify them unto the Lord. For a multitude of the people, even many of Ephraim, and Manasseh, Issachar, and Zebulun, had not cleansed themselves, yet did they eat the passover otherwise than it was written. But Hezekiah prayed for them, saying, The good Lord pardon every one that prepareth his heart to seek God, the Lord God of his fathers, though he be not cleansed according to the purification of the sanctuary. And the Lord hearkened to Hezekiah, and healed the people.

Let us therefore, as many as be perfect, be thus minded: and if in any thing ye be otherwise minded, God shall reveal even this unto you.

Not all error is always necessarily indicative of an unregenerate heart.  I think we saw this reflected also in 2 Thessalonians 3:6, 14-15 earlier as well:

Now we command you, brethren, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye withdraw yourselves from every brother that walketh disorderly, and not after the tradition which he received of us. . . . And if any man obey not our word by this epistle, note that man, and have no company with him, that he may be ashamed. Yet count him not as an enemy, but admonish him as a brother.  (2 Thessalonians 3:6, 14-15)

Notice that even though this person, who has rejected something that God has commanded, is put out of the fellowship of the church (thus being treated, in Jesus's words, as a "heathen and a tax collector"), yet it is not asserted that in his heart he actually is a heathen; instead, he is still considered a brother even while he is being put out of fellowship.

So we can say that there are different degrees of error in doctrine and practice.  Some forms of erring indicate pretty clearly an unregenerate state, while other forms of erring may be consistent with a regenerate state.  If the Bible (or reason) indicates that something in particular is necessarily incompatible with regeneration, then we must see it that way.  If the Bible (or reason) does not indicate that something in particular is necessarily incompatible with a regenerate state, we are allowed, and indeed I would say it is our duty as those who ought to give a quick ear to a good report but be slow to hear a bad one, to have hope, so long as and to the degree which the particular case warrants it, that a person's heart is overall in the right place.  Of course, we cannot know for sure in a given case that a person's heart is in the right place, since we cannot see into people's hearts, but we can have hope in a judgment of charity.

I think that this passage just quoted above from 2 Thessalonians is indicative of how the church should deal with those who commit sins and refuse to abandon them.  In contrast to the latitudinarian practice, the fact that a person may very well be a true brother at heart is not invoked as a good reason not to exercise church discipline against him.  Church courts cannot see into the hearts of individual people any more than anyone else can.  If a person refuses to present his child for baptism, and there are no other signs that he is intentionally rebelling against God, who can say for sure if he is sinning more willfully or more in confusion or ignorance?  But what can be said is that he is sinning, because he is doing something against the commands of God.  The church must judge his outward actions; it cannot examine his heart and declare it (relatively) innocent (or guilty, in this case).  God will take care of such a person and deal with him according to his true inward nature (and his friends on an informal level can treat him as a judgment of charity would warrant), but the church in its formal capacity must carry out its God-given task to use teaching and church discipline to train the members of the church in everything that Christ has commanded.  The church should use gentleness in trying to better instruct the ignorant, but if it cannot bring a person to conform to the commands of Christ, it must not allow him into its formal fellowship (if he is outside) and it must put him out of its formal fellowship (if he is inside).

IMPLICATIONS FOR THE UNITY OF THE VISIBLE CHURCH

So we see that the latitudinarian practice does not have warrant in the Word of God but is rather opposed by it.  This has implications not only for how churches should carry out church discipline and how they should go about admitting people into formal membership, but it also has implications for the seeking of the unity of the visible church.  Latitudinarians will sometimes suggest that church unity between divided denominations ought to be sought for at least partly by churches agreeing to disagree about various doctrinal or practical matters or allowing such tolerated disagreement to exist within themselves.  For example, my wife and I used to attend a Free Methodist church back in Wheaton, IL, when we were in college.  We had our first child while living there, and the pastor of that church baptized our child, telling us that his policy was to do a baby baptism if that is what the parents wanted or a baby dedication if that is what they wanted.  He was OK to go either way, and to tolerate both practices in the church.  In the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, all pastors are required to believe in infant baptism themselves, and they would never do a baby dedication, but it is common to allow baptists to be members and not discipline them for not having their children baptized.  Another example of common latitudinarian practice in Reformed circles is to allow diversity within the church over exclusive psalmody.  Individual churches and pastors/elders and members might be allowed to believe in and practice exclusive psalmody, while others would be allowed to reject that view.  One of the most interesting examples of a latitudinarian proposal I have seen to date is one by W. Robert Godfrey, a Reformed theologian, in an article in Modern Reformation magazine.  In the article, Godfrey suggests that we should try to achieve denominational unity in the Reformed world by merging the existing denominations into one while allowing all the different parts of the new denomination to keep their distinctive doctrines and practices.  So we might have a single Reformed denomination with one presbytery which practices (and enforces within itself) exclusive pslamody, another presbytery which rejects it, some which tolerate both views, etc., and the General Assembly of the overall denomination would not be allowed to overrule the individual presbyteries in these matters.

But, however popular latitudinarian thinking is in the evangelical and Reformed churches today, we have seen that it is contrary to biblical teaching as to the duty of the church in teaching and enforcing everything that Christ has commanded.  Church discipline cannot connive at any clear errors in doctrine or practice at any level (whether within a single congregation or at a provincial or synodical level).  Godfrey's proposal is helpful in that it attempts to preserve the idea of denominational unity, something many Reformed people have not taken seriously enough in recent times, but it wants to preserve such unity at the expense of the preservation of "all the counsel of God" (Acts 20:27--emphasis added).  The Bible presents a different picture of how to go about achieving denominational unity:

Now I beseech you, brethren, by the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye all speak the same thing, and that there be no divisions among you; but that ye be perfectly joined together in the same mind and in the same judgment. (1 Corinthians 1:10)

Now the God of patience and consolation grant you to be like-minded one toward another according to Christ Jesus; that ye may with one mind and one mouth glorify God, even the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ. (Romans 15:5)

Only let your conversation be as becometh the gospel of Christ, that whether I come and see you, or else be absent, I may hear of your affairs, that ye stand fast in one spirit, with one mind striving together for the faith of the gospel.  (Philippians 1:27)

If the church is commanded by Christ to preach and enforce everything that he has commanded, then the full, formal unity of the church can only be brought about when all Christians and all visible churches come to full unity in doctrine and practice in accordance with all that God has taught and commanded us to believe and do.  In contrast to the popular phrase I quoted toward the beginning of this article, the proper, biblical phrase should be this:  "In essentials unity, in non-essentials unity, and in all things charity."  Where God's revelation is not clear or definitive, we should allow diversity and liberty, but not where it speaks clearly and definitively.

WHAT ABOUT THE "WEAK" AND THE "STRONG" BRETHREN FROM ROMANS 14?

In Romans 14:1-15:2, Paul discusses what the attitude of the members of the church should be with regard to what he calls "weak" and "strong" members:

Him that is weak in the faith receive ye, but not to doubtful disputations. For one believeth that he may eat all things: another, who is weak, eateth herbs. Let not him that eateth despise him that eateth not; and let not him which eateth not judge him that eateth: for God hath received him. Who art thou that judgest another man's servant? to his own master he standeth or falleth. Yea, he shall be holden up: for God is able to make him stand. One man esteemeth one day above another: another esteemeth every day alike. Let every man be fully persuaded in his own mind. He that regardeth the day, regardeth it unto the Lord; and he that regardeth not the day, to the Lord he doth not regard it. He that eateth, eateth to the Lord, for he giveth God thanks; and he that eateth not, to the Lord he eateth not, and giveth God thanks. For none of us liveth to himself, and no man dieth to himself. For whether we live, we live unto the Lord; and whether we die, we die unto the Lord: whether we live therefore, or die, we are the Lord's. For to this end Christ both died, and rose, and revived, that he might be Lord both of the dead and living. But why dost thou judge thy brother? or why dost thou set at nought thy brother? for we shall all stand before the judgment seat of Christ. For it is written, As I live, saith the Lord, every knee shall bow to me, and every tongue shall confess to God. So then every one of us shall give account of himself to God. Let us not therefore judge one another any more: but judge this rather, that no man put a stumblingblock or an occasion to fall in his brother's way. I know, and am persuaded by the Lord Jesus, that there is nothing unclean of itself: but to him that esteemeth any thing to be unclean, to him it is unclean. But if thy brother be grieved with thy meat, now walkest thou not charitably. Destroy not him with thy meat, for whom Christ died. Let not then your good be evil spoken of: For the kingdom of God is not meat and drink; but righteousness, and peace, and joy in the Holy Ghost. For he that in these things serveth Christ is acceptable to God, and approved of men. Let us therefore follow after the things which make for peace, and things wherewith one may edify another. For meat destroy not the work of God. All things indeed are pure; but it is evil for that man who eateth with offence. It is good neither to eat flesh, nor to drink wine, nor any thing whereby thy brother stumbleth, or is offended, or is made weak. Hast thou faith? have it to thyself before God. Happy is he that condemneth not himself in that thing which he alloweth. And he that doubteth is damned if he eat, because he eateth not of faith: for whatsoever is not of faith is sin. We then that are strong ought to bear the infirmities of the weak, and not to please ourselves. Let every one of us please his neighbour for his good to edification.

Some have attempted to argue in behalf of latitudinarian principles from what Paul says here.  According to them, what Paul is saying is this:  "Don't worry about minor doctrines.  You don't have to be agreed on all doctrinal points in the church.  If some people, for example, think that no days are holy, and others think that there are some holy days, each person should hold his own beliefs on the matter and continue to keep unity with those who think differently.  There is no need to divide the church over these kinds of things; both views should be accepted within the church."  The implication would be, of course, that over such "minor" doctrinal differences there should be no church discipline.

The problem with this is that latitudinarians have misconstrued Paul's thoughts here.  For simplicity, let's continue to focus on the issue of holy days.  Paul is not saying that it makes no difference if some people believe, say, April 15 to be a holy day, set apart by God, while other people don't.  It is a sin to add to the worship of God.  Only God can make a holy day, and the Bible elsewhere (including in Paul) portrays it as sinful to make up a holy day out of one's imagination.  In Galatians 4:1-8, for example, Paul makes it clear that observing holy days not commanded by God (whether the holy days of the Old Covenant dispensation or simply man-invented holy days) is not at all OK:

Howbeit then, when ye knew not God, ye did service unto them which by nature are no gods. But now, after that ye have known God, or rather are known of God, how turn ye again to the weak and beggarly elements, whereunto ye desire again to be in bondage? Ye observe days, and months, and times, and years. I am afraid of you, lest I have bestowed upon you labour in vain.

We remember that this was one of the great sins of Jeroboam, whereby he made Israel to sin (1 Kings 12:32-33):

And Jeroboam ordained a feast in the eighth month, on the fifteenth day of the month, like unto the feast that is in Judah, and he offered upon the altar. So did he in Bethel, sacrificing unto the calves that he had made: and he placed in Bethel the priests of the high places which he had made. So he offered upon the altar which he had made in Bethel the fifteenth day of the eighth month, even in the month which he had devised of his own heart; and ordained a feast unto the children of Israel: and he offered upon the altar, and burnt incense.

I've discussed this issue more fully here.  So Paul is not saying in Romans 14 that it is fine to make up holy days out of one's imagination.  Then what is he saying?  The answer appears upon a closer inspection of Romans 14.  Note that the "weak" man (in this case, the one who "observes the day") and the"strong" man are told by Paul not to judge each other but to accept each other.  The person who observes the day is not to accuse the person who does not observe it with sin, and vice versa.  If we were talking here about two people, one of whom holds the doctrinal position that it is a sin to observe, say, April 15 as a holy day and the other of whom holds that it is a sin not to observe April 15, it would be impossible that these two individuals should not accuse each other of sin.  They would have to regard each other as committing sin, because they would believe each other to be violating the commands of God.  But here they are told not to do this but to accept each other as offering acceptable service to God.  They are not to "despise" or judge each other but to receive each other.  So we are not talking here about two contradictory doctrinal positions.  Then what are we talking about?  What is in view here are two individuals, both of whom know as a matter of objective doctrine that the holy days of the previous Old Covenant dispensation have been abolished, but one of whom still feels a psychological conscientiousness, built into him no doubt by his past upbringing and experience, that causes him to feel uncomfortable not observing the holy days of that dispensation.  He does not say that God has commanded them when God has not, which would be a sin, and would require him to accuse the "strong" person of sin or think of him as committing sin.  He knows that they are not objectively commanded by God, but he chooses to observe them anyway out of something like a psychological need to do so.  So, in this case, the two individuals are in doctrinal agreement, but one of them is more free of psychological pressure to observe certain objectively unnecessary things than the other.  That is why Paul can write his letter addressing both persons, the "strong" and the "weak," and tell them to bear with each other.  The only way the "weak" could recognize and obey Paul's instructions addressed to themselves would be if they know that they are weak, which would not be the case if they were in doctrinal error.  The "weak" know they are weak because they are aware of the true doctrine and why they feel a need to observe the special days.  In this case, the "weak" and the "strong" are not to look down upon each other or to judge each other but are to accept each other, recognizing the differences between them and that God has accepted them both and that both are serving him.

We saw earlier that Paul requires church discipline for those who refuse to obey the words of his epistles, even if they might be true brothers at heart.  Right here in Romans 14, Paul makes it clear that the doctrinal position that holds that the holy days must be observed (and that meat is not to be eaten) is in error.  If a person were to receive the epistle to the Romans, then, and continue to hold as a doctrine that it is necessary to observe the Old Covenant holy days, he would be rejecting Paul's teaching in the epistle, which would require church discipline.  And yet Paul says that the "weak" person is not to be looked down upon or judged but is to be accepted and maintained in the unity of the church.  As I noted above, the fact that Paul addresses instructions to the "weak" as to how they should treat the "strong" indicates that they are to recognize themselves as the "weak," but if the "weak" are those who hold false doctrinal positions on holy days and other matters, to recognize themselves would be to be aware that they are wrong and then continue to persist in their error, thus willfully rejecting the teaching of the apostle.  But, from what we've seen, it is clear that Paul calls for church discipline on this sort of person, and yet no discipline is called for in the case of the "weak."  Again, this indicates that we are not dealing here with people who hold false doctrine but with people who know objectively what is true and acknowledge it but still feel an attachment themselves to the observance of holy days (and not eating meat, etc.).

So there is no basis here for the latitudinarian position.  We are to bear with each others' varying subjective states and comfort levels in various areas and try not to unnecessarily scandalize or offend each other when sin is not involved, but this does not mean that the church is not to discipline church members when sin is involved.

SOME THOUGHTS FROM REV. THOMAS M'CRIE

In conclusion, I would like to present some thoughts from Rev. Thomas M'Crie, the great Scottish Presbyterian theologian, as he comments on some of the things that have been discussed throughout this article, from his excellent book, The Unity of the Church.  (In addition, I would like to recommend a very helpful article from Rev. John T. Pressly.)  Here is M'Crie:


Mournful as the divisions of the Church are, and anxious as all its genuine friends must be to see them cured, it is their duty to examine carefully the plans which may be proposed for attaining this desirable end. We must not do evil that good may come; and there are sacrifices too costly to be made for the procuring of peace with fellow Christians. 
Is it necessary to remind you, that unity and peace are not always good, nor a sure and infallible mark of a true and pure church? We know that there is a church which has long boasted of her catholic unity notwithstanding all the corruptions which pollute her communion; and that within her pale the whole world called Christian once enjoyed a profound repose, and it could be said, "Behold, the people is one, and they have all one language" (Gen. 11:6). It was a union and peace founded in ignorance, delusion, implicit faith, and a base subjection to human authority; and supported by the arts of compulsion and terror.

But there are other methods by which Christians may be deceived, and the interests of religion deeply injured, under the pretext or with the view of uniting its friends. Among these I know none more imposing, nor from which greater danger is to be apprehended in the present time, than that which proceeds on the scheme of principles usually styled latitudinarian.

It has obtained this name because it proclaims an undue latitude in matters of religion, which persons may take to themselves or give to others. Its abettors make light of the differences which subsist among religious parties, and propose to unite them on the common principles on which they are already agreed, in the way of burying the rest in silence, or of stipulating mutual forbearance and charity with respect to everything about which they may differ in opinion or in practice.

Some plead for this on the ground that the several professions of religion differ very little from one another, and are all conducive to the happiness of mankind and the honor of God, who is pleased with the various diversified modes in which men profess their regard to him, provided only they are sincere in their professions ­ a principle of difformity which, however congenial to the system of polytheism, is utterly eversive of a religion founded on the unity of the divine nature and will, and on a revelation which teaches us what we are to believe concerning God and what duty he requires of us.

But the ground on which this plan is ordinarily made to rest is a distinction made among the articles of religion. Some of these are called essential, or fundamental, or necessary, or principal; others circumstantial, or non-fundamental, or unnecessary, or less important. The former, it is pleaded, are embraced by all true Christians; the latter form the subjects of difference among them, and ought not to enter into the terms of ecclesiastical fellowship.[8] On this principle some of them would conciliate and unite all the Christian denominations, not excepting Papists, Arians, and Socinians; while others restrict their plan to those called evangelical, who differ mainly in their views and practice as to the worship, order, and discipline of the Church.

The distinction on which this scheme rests is itself liable to objections which appear insuperable. It is not warranted by the Word of God; and the most acute of its defenders have never been able to state it in a manner that is satisfactory, or which renders it subservient to any practical use. The Scripture, indeed, speaks of certain truths which may be called the foundation, because they are first laid, and others depend on them ­ first principles, or elementary truths, which are to be taught before others. But their priority or posteriority in point of order, in conception or instruction, does not determine the relative importance of doctrines, or their necessity in order to salvation. Far less does it determine the propriety of their being made to enter into the religious profession of Christians and Christian churches.

There are doctrines, too, which intrinsically, and on different accounts, may be said to have a peculiar and superior degree of importance; and this, so far as known, may properly be urged as a motive for our giving the more earnest heed to them. It is not, however, their comparative importance or utility, but their truth and the authority of him who has revealed them, which is the formal and proper reason of our receiving, professing, and maintaining them. And this applies equally to all the contents of a divine revelation. The relations of truths, especially those of a supernatural kind, are manifold and incomprehensible to us; it is not our part to pronounce a judgment on them; and if we could see them as God does, in all their extent and at once, we would behold the lesser joined to the greater, the most remote connected with the primary, by necessary and indissoluble links, and all together conspiring to form one beautiful and harmonious and indivisible whole.

Whatever God has revealed we are bound to receive and hold fast; whatever he has enjoined we are bound to obey; and the liberty which we dare not arrogate to ourselves we cannot give to others. It is not, indeed, necessary that the confession or testimony of the Church (meaning by this that which is explicitly made by her, as distinguished from her declared adherence to the whole Word of God) should contain all truths. But then any of them may come to be included in it, when opposed and endangered; and it is no sufficient reason for excluding any of them that they are less important than others, or that they have been doubted and denied by good and learned men. Whatever forbearance may be exercised to persons, "the Word of the Lord," in all its extent, "must have free course and be glorified" (cf. 2 Thess. 3:1). And any act of men ­ call it forbearance or what you will ­ which serves as a screen and protection to error or sin, and prevents it from being opposed and removed by any proper means, is contrary to the divine law, and consequently is destitute of all intrinsic force and validity.

There are truths also which are more immediately connected with salvation. But who will pretend to fix those propositions which are absolutely necessary to be known in order to salvation, by all persons, of all capacities, and in all situations; or say how low a God of grace and salvation may descend in dealing with particular individuals? Or, if we could determine this extreme point, who would say that it ought to fix the rule of our dealing with others, or the extent of a church's profession of faith? Is nothing else to be kept in view in settling articles of faith and fellowship, but what may be necessary to the salvation of sinners? Do we not owe a paramount regard to the glory of God in the highest, to the edifying of the body of Christ, to the advancing of the general interests of religion, and to the preserving, in purity, of those external means, by which, in the economy of providence and grace, the salvation of men, both initial and progressive, may be promoted to an incalculable extent from age to age?

In fine, there is reason for complaining that the criteria or marks given for determining these fundamental or necessary articles are uncertain or contradictory. It is alleged that "they are clearly taught in Scripture?" This is true of the others also. "That they are few and simple?" This is contradicted by their own attempts to state them. "That they are such as the Scripture has declared to be necessary?" Why then have we not yet been furnished with a catalogue of them? "That they are such as embraced by all true Christians?" Have they a secret tact by which they are able to discover such characters? If not, can they avoid running into a vicious circle in reasoning, by first determining who are true Christians by their embracing certain doctrines, and then determining that these doctrines are fundamental because they are embraced by persons of that description?
Many who have contributed to give currency to this scheme have been actuated, I have no doubt, by motives which are in themselves highly commendable. They wished to fix the attention of men on matters confessedly of great importance, and were anxious to put an end to the dissensions of Christians by discovering a mean point in which the views of all might harmoniously meet. But surely those who cherish a supreme regard for divine authority will be afraid of contemning or of teaching others to think lightly of anything which bears its sacred impress. They will be disposed carefully to reconsider an opinion, or an interpretation of any part of Scripture, which seems to imply in it that God has given men a power to dispense with some of his own laws. And they will be cautious of originating or countenancing plans of communion that may involve a principle of such a complexion.

These plans are more or less dangerous according to the extent to which they are carried, and the errors or abuses which may prevail among the parties which they embrace. But however limited they may be, they set an example which may be carried to any extent. So far as it is agreed and stipulated that any truth or duty shall be sacrificed or neglected, and that any error or sin shall be treated as indifferent or trivial, the essence of latitudinarianism is adopted, room is made for further advancements, and the way is prepared for ascending, through successive generations, to the very highest degree in the scale.

UPDATE 1/30/15:  Rev. David Campbell of the FPCS quotes in this article from the Original Secession Church Testimony here, which speaks plainly and strongly against latitudinarianism.